Capri, the pearl of the Mediterranean, immediately evokes sumptuous landscapes, a turquoise sea, and a gentle way of life prized by travelers from around the world. But behind this postcard, two questions arise:

• Is the island as safe as it seems?
• Are there any areas to avoid in Capri?

Currently, Italy is experiencing a rise in crimes targeting tourists in its major cities, and we will see that the trend is the same in Capri.

So, should you be worried about the island's safety, and above all, are there any neighborhoods or areas to avoid during your stay? This article takes stock, free from clichés, so you can enjoy Capri with complete peace of mind!

Is Capri a dangerous island?

Contrary to its reputation as a safe island, in 2025 Capri displays a fairly high crime index compared to the Italian average. In fact, it is 68 for Capri while the Italian average is 49. But this crime mainly concerns thefts and burglaries. 

Indeed, in recent years there have been numerous incidents of petty crime, particularly thefts from villas, hotels, and clubs in the center, especially during the peak tourist season. See the article published on ilfattoquotidiano.it, who explains that this wave of crimes has caused the safety rating of the island favored by footballers and captains of industry to plummet. So much so that the mayors of Capri and Anacapri, Ciro Lembo and Francesco Cerrotta, have requested the installation of new security cameras linked to the police force's operational centers.

Fortunately, unlike Naples and just like at SorrentoViolent crime remains rare in Capri. However, vigilance is advised, especially in busy areas and in the evening.

Please note that local authorities carry out checks on land and at sea to ensure the safety of residents and tourists, including with regard to drug trafficking, even if it is limited.

Areas to avoid in Capri

There are no red light districts or dangerous areas in Capri as such as there may be in Rome., Milan ou Turin.

However, there are certain areas to avoid due to the presence of petty crime and for reasons of comfort, tranquility or lack of tourist interest.

Indeed, pickpocketing can occur in the busiest areas such as the Piazzetta et the port of Marina Grande.

Overall, the historic center of Capri (Piazzetta and surrounding areas) should be avoided if you're looking for a quiet stay. This area is so lively in the summer that it becomes noisy and unrefreshing.

And, of course, to avoid any problems, it is best not to venture out alone onto the trails or outlying areas after dark, as safety is considered low in these conditions.

The most beautiful places to stay in Capri

The majority of tourists choose to stay in the Piazzetta or the family Marina Grande port because these are the two most touristy areas of Capri.

But you should know that stars and football players generally prefer the most beautiful places, the quiet and exclusive areas of Capri for their stay.

If you want to know them, here are the most popular areas of Capri:

• Marina Piccola (particularly popular with celebrities): This area in the south of the island offers a more secluded setting, a splendid view of the Faraglioni, and a private port where celebrity yachts dock. The area is appreciated for its privacy and tranquility, although the beach can get crowded during high season.
• Anacapri : Located on the hills to the west of the island, this village also seduces visitors with its peaceful atmosphere, spectacular views, and authenticity. That's why I recommend choosing this area to best enjoy Capri.

Anacapri: Preferred area

To enjoy a tourist stay in Capri while being in peace and quiet, choose Anacapri, in the west of the island.

This hilltop village offers an authentic and peaceful atmosphere, far from the hustle and bustle of Capri town. You'll find charming little streets and must-see sites like Monte Solaro (panoramic view), Villa San Michele, and the famous Blue Grotto.

For an exceptional stay in Anacapri, two hotels stand out for their luxury, their history and their spectacular views of the Bay of Naples: Hotel Caesar Augustus et Jumeirah Capri Palace.

Hotel Caesar Augustus

This iconic property, housed in a historic villa, offers an unparalleled experience thanks to its infinity pool overlooking the sea, its gourmet restaurant, its spa and its panoramic terraces.

It is the most beautiful hotel in Anacapri for its breathtaking views, refinement, and personalized service, although its exclusive atmosphere is more suited to travelers seeking tranquility and prestige.

Jumeirah Capri Palace

This five-star palace combines contemporary elegance, history and art, with an award-winning spa, two swimming pools, a private beach and top-notch dining.

It stands out for its sophisticated atmosphere, artistic decor and quiet location away from the center, but its more international style will especially appeal to lovers of high-end design and well-being.